Research Paper Analysis Coordinator
Meta-prompting system for comprehensive research paper analysis using multiple AI specialist perspectives
8.2/10Overall
8.2AI
No user ratings
Academic Writing & Research
Template
For: Claude 4, GPT-4.1 - Academic research and peer review1 viewsSubmitted Jul 18AI evaluated Jul 18
Prompt
<meta_research_director>
I'm coordinating a comprehensive analysis of this research paper by deploying multiple AI specialists.
Paper: {paper_title}
Authors: {authors}
Domain: {research_domain}
Specialist teams needed:
1. Technical Reviewer - methodology and validity
2. Literature Expert - context and positioning
3. Practical Evaluator - real-world applications
4. Critical Analyst - limitations and biases
</meta_research_director>
<specialist_reviews>
## Technical Review
As a methodological expert in {domain}:
- Research design assessment: {technical_analysis}
- Statistical validity: {statistical_review}
- Experimental rigor: {experimental_assessment}
## Literature Context Review
As a literature specialist in {domain}:
- Field positioning: {literature_context}
- Novel contributions: {novelty_assessment}
- Citation analysis: {citation_review}
## Practical Application Review
As an industry application expert:
- Real-world relevance: {practical_relevance}
- Implementation feasibility: {implementation_analysis}
- Commercial potential: {commercial_assessment}
## Critical Analysis Review
As a critical thinking specialist:
- Potential biases: {bias_analysis}
- Methodological limitations: {limitation_analysis}
- Alternative interpretations: {alternative_views}
</specialist_reviews>
<meta_synthesis>
Integrating all specialist perspectives:
Key strengths of this research:
{Synthesized_strengths}
Areas of concern or limitation:
{Synthesized_limitations}
Significance and impact:
{Impact_assessment}
Recommendations for future work:
{Future_directions}
Overall assessment:
{Final_comprehensive_evaluation}
</meta_synthesis>
AI Evaluation
How we evaluateClaude 3 Haiku
AI Evaluation
8.1/10
GPT-4 Mini
AI Evaluation
8.4/10
User Rating
No ratings yet. Be the first to rate!
Rate this prompt
Your 5-star rating is doubled to match our 10-point scale for fair comparison with AI scores.